Michael Robertson: Thoughts on Lala.com

Since Lala’s newly-relaunched music service includes a “music locker” feature that is virtually identical to one that Michael Robertson pioneered with MyMP3 back in 2000 — only to ultimately be sued into oblivion by the RIAA — I emailed him to get his thoughts on what the company is doing, and how things have (or haven’t) changed since he first launched MP3.com. Here’s what he said in response:

“I really admire what Lala is trying to do. Their user interface is nice and concept as you pointed out is one I championed in 2000. The world has changed dramatically since I did my.mp3 in 2000, but sadly the labels have not. My belief back then was that users should have rights to move their own music around. Music lovers want the music everywhere on any device. This means you must support an open API instead of locking users to a single service. This means you must support downloads not just streaming.

Lala is loaded with crippling restrictions which the labels force on them which limit its usefulness (but that’s no fault of their own). e.g If you buy a song from Lala it is automaticaly put into your locker but goes to solitary confinement. You can never, ever download it again. It is locked with server side DRM. If you’re at work when you bought it and need the song at home you’re out of luck. If you want to listen to the song on your mobile phone while in the dentist chair (which I did today) too bad. Consumers are still treated like criminals.

Music in the cloud is a concept who’s time has come but any solution needs to honor the consumer’s right to listen to their music anywhere they want. It needs to work with all computers, home devices, and mobile devices. It needs to offer download and streaming because it will be a decade or more before we all have ubiquitous wireless broadband at a small flat fee. It’s imperative that the system have an API open to every device manufacturer and developer so users don’t find their music trapped with one company or one set of devices.”

Michael is currently embroiled in another music industry lawsuit over an online music service he launched called MP3Tunes.com, which also offers a music-locker feature and was eventually sued by EMI (CNET has more on that suit here). Music-industry gadfly Bob Lefsetz has a take on Lala as well, in his own inimitable style.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: