This is what happens when speech gets outsourced to Twitter and Facebook

Both Facebook and Twitter are struggling to get a handle on how their platforms are being used by bad actors, but their solutions are causing almost as many problems as they had before they started. In the case of Facebook, the giant social network is clamping down on political advertising, and that is creating some bad blood among news publishers, who believe they are being unfairly treated. In Twitter’s case, the company is trying to curb harassment, but the ways it has chosen to do so are raising a host of unpleasant questions about its power and how that affects publishers and free speech.

Facebook has been building an archive of political ads, as a way of making up for the fact that Russian trolls manipulated the platform during the 2016 election, but news companies are being caught in that net, and they are not happy about it. Reveal, an investigative news outlet, complained this week that it was blocked from promoting a news story because Facebook said it was political advertising, and others have complained of similar behavior. Most say they have gotten a message saying they “are not approved to post political advertising” when they try to boost a post with a political news story.

(tweets)

Rob Goldman, head of advertising for Facebook, explained in a series of tweets on Wednesday that this happens because the news outlets in question haven’t been “authenticated” and approved to post political ads, and paying to promote a post with a political news story in it qualifies as a political ad. Megha **, engagement editor at STAT News, said the site had been blocked from promoting stories in the past, but after getting authenticated — which involved a page administrator supplying photo ID and a special code sent by mail — there hasn’t been a problem. This doesn’t change the fact that many media entities, including The New York Times, believe they shouldn’t have to go through this process at all, however.

In the case of Twitter, the company blocked a range of accounts — including many run by journalists — for 24 hours, after they posted messages about a story published by Splinter News (formerly Gawker Media, now part of Univision) that included the private phone number of White House senior policy adviser Stephen Miller, the person many blame for the separation and internment of immigrant families. Twitter apparently saw publishing his phone number as “doxxing,” or revealing personal information about someone for the purposes of harassment, and therefore put the users in “Twitter jail.”

(tweets)

Whether posting Miller’s phone number should be seen as doxxing is obviously up to Twitter to decide, as is the punishment for this supposed crime, since it (like Facebook) is a private corporation running a platform it controls, and thus isn’t bound by the First Amendment. That said, however, blocking someone for simply posting a link to a website raises some interesting questions. How far is Twitter — or any other platform — willing to go in taking this to its logical conclusion? What if a journalist links to a site that has ISIS videos, or pro-Nazi content, for news purposes. Will they be blocked?

The reality of the internet as it exists right now is that several large platforms effectively control speech in a much more dramatic and far-reaching way than was ever possible in the past. Google and Facebook and Twitter are like shopping malls, where the mall owner gets to control the speech of anyone who enters, but these malls include literally billions people all across the globe, and the speech that occurs there — including journalism — has very real social consequences. The algorithms these companies are using to curb certain kinds of speech, meanwhile, tend to be both erratic and clumsy. Can the platforms find a way out of this Catch 22 without stomping all over publishers and users?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s